My peeps have weighed in about the Notorious D.O.C. cover. One line stood out to me. “The grey is more serious and the red is more sexy.” (Unrelated photo below, demonstrating serious +/- sexy.)
One shoe on, one off makes it clear that she’s hit “instead of tinkering under the car”
Some like the tire tread and blood
Works as a thumbnail
Red draws attention to the title
“I don’t like her body.”
“I don’t like her butt. It should be more toned. Is she someone who works out?”
“What’s with the panty line?”
“I don’t like the dress colour.”
“Yeah, the grey on grey.”
“I can’t tell at a glance if she’s face-up or face-down.”
“I don’t like the reflection in the car—it took me a minute to figure out what it was.”
“Why is she wearing flip flops? Why is she wearing a dress?”
Tire tread not realistic-looking
Paw print on the book spine (Olo Books logo)—unclear what this is
Red top draws the eye
Red is the colour of blood (and is sexier!)
Model has Asian background, like the Lisa Lee character in the book (very important to me, as I hate whitewashed covers)
Shot in the rain, also like the book
Rollerblades in the background (part of the book—Lisa Lee was blading in the wee hours of the morning)
Model wearing work-out clothes
Body angle not as eye-catching
Car wheel distracting
“Looks like it was shot in a garage with a reflective floor”
Not clear what the Rollerblades are in the background
No tire tread
Both shoes on
Both covers have strengths and weaknesses. But, in the end, my two covers are not so much competing against each other as competing against every other cover in the world.
The people who really disliked the grey cover were the ones who saw it in person. So it’s entirely possible that the grey works better online and the red works better face to face.
Which is a tricky question, since most people will buy this book online. It will be available to order in bookstores, but most people will see it on Amazon or as an e-book first—the opposite of the days of yore.
Which makes me wonder if I could have a different cover for e-book or print—or if I just have to choose the one that looks better as a thumbnail rather than in real life, which is an interesting reversal of fortunes.
First I have to get a copy of the red in print. Then I’ll decide. However, my decision will not be set in stone. And this is not a democracy. (Even if it were, only 22 people have voted so far, with the vote 13 to 9 in favour of the grey, which is not a stunning sample size.) Ultimately, I will choose the cover, and I may be crazy enough to do it differently for e-book and print book, or make one cover special order. Through the miracle of technology, I can also change my decision later. Hooray for indie publishing, and thanks for taking the time to vote!